Just a fantastic top 25. We're not likely to see what as good ever again...
-
Welcome to Talking Time's third iteration! If you would like to register for an account, or have already registered but have not yet been confirmed, please read the following:
- The CAPTCHA key's answer is "Percy"
- Once you've completed the registration process please email us from the email you used for registration at percyreghelper@gmail.com and include the username you used for registration
Once you have completed these steps, Moderation Staff will be able to get your account approved.
The Rest of the Best - A Popularity Contest 50th Anniversary! Week Seventeen - Marios!
- Thread starter Johnny Unusual
- Start date
-
- Tags
- popularity contest
To elaborate more, this was the contest that made me decide to try one myself, and to really go all in creatively. Which is very exhausting, it turns out! Especially trying to maintain that over three contests. I have to give it up to JBear and Johnny for truly raising the bar and making this one to remember as an upper echelon of the format.
Johnny Unusual
(He/Him)
MY original list
1. Scrabble
2. Dungeons & Dragons
3. Magic: The Gathering
4. Settlers of Catan
5. Trivial Pursuit
6. Scattergories
7. Avalon: The Resistance
8. Revolution
9. Dominion
10. Puerto Rico
11. Coup
12. 7 Wonders
13. Bang
14. Ticket to Ride
15. Shadowrun
16. Pictionary
17. Marvel Legendary
18. Riddle of Steel
19. Carcassone
20. Poker
21. Apples to Apples
22. Chess
23. Tales of the Arabian Nights
24. Paperback
25. Marvel Heroes
In retrospect, I think I would put Paperback higher. I really like Fowers Games. If you haven't played them, they are pretty fun. Burgle Bros is definitely worth checking out. I actually introduced Coup to my afterschool program. It's not the favourite of the games I brought over (I'll get to that in a bit) but this is a hit. The kids like the idea of a game where they can lie.
I swear, the two people who I know OWN Ticket to Ride, the base game at least, just get to a point where they are DONE with it. Luckily, I only played through it a handful of times.
Scrabble is our family game. My family would play it every other night at our family cottage. And my dad usually wins.
1. Scrabble
2. Dungeons & Dragons
3. Magic: The Gathering
4. Settlers of Catan
5. Trivial Pursuit
6. Scattergories
7. Avalon: The Resistance
8. Revolution
9. Dominion
10. Puerto Rico
11. Coup
12. 7 Wonders
13. Bang
14. Ticket to Ride
15. Shadowrun
16. Pictionary
17. Marvel Legendary
18. Riddle of Steel
19. Carcassone
20. Poker
21. Apples to Apples
22. Chess
23. Tales of the Arabian Nights
24. Paperback
25. Marvel Heroes
In retrospect, I think I would put Paperback higher. I really like Fowers Games. If you haven't played them, they are pretty fun. Burgle Bros is definitely worth checking out. I actually introduced Coup to my afterschool program. It's not the favourite of the games I brought over (I'll get to that in a bit) but this is a hit. The kids like the idea of a game where they can lie.
I swear, the two people who I know OWN Ticket to Ride, the base game at least, just get to a point where they are DONE with it. Luckily, I only played through it a handful of times.
Scrabble is our family game. My family would play it every other night at our family cottage. And my dad usually wins.
Johnny Unusual
(He/Him)
Host: @Issun
Participants:
@Octopus Prime @Doctor Nerd @Westerhof @Johnny Unusual @Patrick @Daikaiju @conchobhar @spineshark @Peklo @Rascally Badger @WildcatJF @Bulgakov @q 3 @ASandoval @Juno @Purple @dosboot @ajr82 @breakman @madhair60 @Rya @Galadrome @Alpha Werewolf @Yimothy @Taeryn @Lokii @Gerad @Dracula @Adrenaline @MCBanjoMike @Adam @ThornGhost @JBear @muteKi @Ample Vigour @Positronic Brain @Grignr @karzac @Kirin @Torzelbaum @Rivers @Sami @Kishi @Bunk Moreland @4-So @le geek @lilfut @Fonts Sizes
I love video games but there are a lot of blindspots in my modern gaming experience. I feel like I've personally missed a lot of the big games of the 20th century. Still, this list was a delight and I remember having a lot of fun doing it. Issun hosts this one bringing us to a look at the most popular games of what was then 17 years. I definitely played a fair number of them but a lot are on my "to-do" list. I really want to get around to playing most of the Zelda games some day (so far, only original, A Link to the Past and Ocarina of Time for me).
What di you all think of this one?
Participants:
@Octopus Prime @Doctor Nerd @Westerhof @Johnny Unusual @Patrick @Daikaiju @conchobhar @spineshark @Peklo @Rascally Badger @WildcatJF @Bulgakov @q 3 @ASandoval @Juno @Purple @dosboot @ajr82 @breakman @madhair60 @Rya @Galadrome @Alpha Werewolf @Yimothy @Taeryn @Lokii @Gerad @Dracula @Adrenaline @MCBanjoMike @Adam @ThornGhost @JBear @muteKi @Ample Vigour @Positronic Brain @Grignr @karzac @Kirin @Torzelbaum @Rivers @Sami @Kishi @Bunk Moreland @4-So @le geek @lilfut @Fonts Sizes
#50: Suikoden III
#49: The Last of Us
#48: Silent Hill 2
#47: Rez
#46: The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
#45 World of Warcraft
#44: Overwatch
#43: Etrian Odyssey
#42: Team Fortress 2
#41: Final Fantasy XII
#40: Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater
#39: Metroid: Zero Mission
#38: Final Fantasy X
#37: Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
#36 Valkyria Chronicles
#35 Half-Life 2
#34: Sid Meier's Civilization V
#33: Journey
#32: Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne
#31: Tactics Ogre: Let Us Cling Together
#30: Warioware, Inc.: Mega Microgame$!
#29: Bloodborne
#28: Final Fantasy IX
#27: Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King
#26: Ōkami
#25: Etrian Odyssey IV: Legends of the Titan
#24: Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective
#23: Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3
#22: Super Smash Bros. Melee
#21: Mass Effect 2
#20: XCOM: Enemy Unknown
#19: Cave Story
#18: BioShock
#17: The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask
#16: Shovel Knight
#15: Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4
#14: Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow
#13: ICO
#12: Portal 2
#11: The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker
#10: The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds
#9: Dark Souls
#8: Katamari Damacy
#7: Resident Evil 4
#6: Undertale
#5: Shadow of the Colossus
#4: Portal
#3: Super Mario Galaxy
#2: Metroid Prime
#1: The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
#49: The Last of Us
#48: Silent Hill 2
#47: Rez
#46: The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
#45 World of Warcraft
#44: Overwatch
#43: Etrian Odyssey
#42: Team Fortress 2
#41: Final Fantasy XII
#40: Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater
#39: Metroid: Zero Mission
#38: Final Fantasy X
#37: Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
#36 Valkyria Chronicles
#35 Half-Life 2
#34: Sid Meier's Civilization V
#33: Journey
#32: Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne
#31: Tactics Ogre: Let Us Cling Together
#30: Warioware, Inc.: Mega Microgame$!
#29: Bloodborne
#28: Final Fantasy IX
#27: Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King
#26: Ōkami
#25: Etrian Odyssey IV: Legends of the Titan
#24: Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective
#23: Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3
#22: Super Smash Bros. Melee
#21: Mass Effect 2
#20: XCOM: Enemy Unknown
#19: Cave Story
#18: BioShock
#17: The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask
#16: Shovel Knight
#15: Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4
#14: Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow
#13: ICO
#12: Portal 2
#11: The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker
#10: The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds
#9: Dark Souls
#8: Katamari Damacy
#7: Resident Evil 4
#6: Undertale
#5: Shadow of the Colossus
#4: Portal
#3: Super Mario Galaxy
#2: Metroid Prime
#1: The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
I love video games but there are a lot of blindspots in my modern gaming experience. I feel like I've personally missed a lot of the big games of the 20th century. Still, this list was a delight and I remember having a lot of fun doing it. Issun hosts this one bringing us to a look at the most popular games of what was then 17 years. I definitely played a fair number of them but a lot are on my "to-do" list. I really want to get around to playing most of the Zelda games some day (so far, only original, A Link to the Past and Ocarina of Time for me).
What di you all think of this one?
This was my first Top 50 I ever ran, and it was a lot of fun, and a lot of work, as these tend to be. I got my first look at the behind-the-scenes, so to speak. Spreadsheeting is a task, but it was interesting watching the list take shape, and there's always a sense of anticipation as you get ready to post each entry, waiting to see the reactions and conversation around them.
This was a great list, too. There were games I hadn't played that I finally got around to playing mainly because of it (Link Between Worlds springs immediately to mind), but there are others I still need to get around to playing. It would be interesting to do this list again sometime, with 7 years and a new console generation under our collective belt. Would Breath of the Wild still be #1, I wonder?
This was a great list, too. There were games I hadn't played that I finally got around to playing mainly because of it (Link Between Worlds springs immediately to mind), but there are others I still need to get around to playing. It would be interesting to do this list again sometime, with 7 years and a new console generation under our collective belt. Would Breath of the Wild still be #1, I wonder?
My list would change, but not by as much as I'd have hoped, as I just haven't gotten around to a ton of new games. I would belatedly add BotW, though, lol. Also I'd be forced to put Pokemon GO on, as it's definitely where the biggest chunk of my play time has gone over the last seven years.
I notice I put We <3 Katamari at #3 on my original list - it's a bit more refined than the first game and the one I'd rather replay, but if I'd voted more strategically on name recognition I maybe could've bumped Katamari up a rank or two on the Top50.
Other things I ranked highly that didn't make it: World Ends With You, Retro Game Challenge, Bravely Default, DQ IX.
I notice I put We <3 Katamari at #3 on my original list - it's a bit more refined than the first game and the one I'd rather replay, but if I'd voted more strategically on name recognition I maybe could've bumped Katamari up a rank or two on the Top50.
Other things I ranked highly that didn't make it: World Ends With You, Retro Game Challenge, Bravely Default, DQ IX.
- Life is Strange
- Okami
- Undertale
- Portal
- Dark Souls
- Shadow of the Colossus
- Final Fantasy X
- Hotline Miami
- ICO
- BioShock
- Civilization IV
- Red Dead Redemption
- Mass Effect 2
- Far Cry 3
- The Walking Dead
- Journey
- Final Fantasy IX
- Bastion
- Portal 2
- Shovel Knight
- The Last of Us
- Castle Crashers
- The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker
- Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater
- The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Games that would have been eligible at the time that would be on my list now: NieR: Automata, Super Mario Galaxy 2, The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds, Inside, Night in the Woods, Uncharted 2: Among Thieves.
Games that have come out since that would be on there: Red Dead Redemption 2, Sayonara Wild Hearts, Eastshade, Animal Crossing: New Horizons, What Remains of Edith Finch, Sea of Stars.
Wow, that's half my list changed. I know Last of Us, Skyrim and MGS 3 would fall off. Not sure what the others would be.
Hey, I found my list!
Wild to think some of these would count, like CvS2 and Skies of Arcadia Legends, haha.
Would definitely be different now:
1) Beyond Good & Evil
2) Persona 4
3) Zelda: Breath of the Wild
4) Hotel Dusk: Room 215
5) XCOM: Enemy Within
6) Resident Evil 4
7) Splatoon
8) Skies of Arcadia (Legends)
9) Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow
10) Portal
11) Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King
12) Dead Space 2
13) Shovel Knight
14) Ghost Trick
15) Deus Ex: Human Revolution
16) The Last Story
17) Fire Emblem: Awakening
18) Metroid Prime
19) Dragon Quest IX: Sentinels of the Starry Skies
20) Okami
21) The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind
22) Capcom Vs. SNK 2
23) Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney
24) Sly 2: Band of Thieves
25) Dead Space
2) Persona 4
3) Zelda: Breath of the Wild
4) Hotel Dusk: Room 215
5) XCOM: Enemy Within
6) Resident Evil 4
7) Splatoon
8) Skies of Arcadia (Legends)
9) Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow
10) Portal
11) Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King
12) Dead Space 2
13) Shovel Knight
14) Ghost Trick
15) Deus Ex: Human Revolution
16) The Last Story
17) Fire Emblem: Awakening
18) Metroid Prime
19) Dragon Quest IX: Sentinels of the Starry Skies
20) Okami
21) The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind
22) Capcom Vs. SNK 2
23) Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney
24) Sly 2: Band of Thieves
25) Dead Space
Wild to think some of these would count, like CvS2 and Skies of Arcadia Legends, haha.
Would definitely be different now:
1) Beyond Good & Evil
2) Fire Emblem: Three Houses
3) Resident Evil 4 (2023)
4) Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom
5) Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow
6) Skies of Arcadia (Legends)
7) Hotel Dusk: Room 215
8) XCOM 2: War of the Chosen
9) Metroid Dread
10) Splatoon 3
11) Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King
12) Ghost Trick
13) The Ninja Warriors Once Again (Ninja Saviors)
14) Spiritfarer
15) Portal
16) Super Smash Bros. Ultimate
17) Unicorn Overlord
18) Dead Space 2
19) Untitled Goose Game
20) Celeste
21) Another Code: Recollection
22) Capcom Vs. SNK 2
23) The Last Story
24) Street Fighter 6
25) Shovel Knight: Shovel of Hope (specifically)
2) Fire Emblem: Three Houses
3) Resident Evil 4 (2023)
4) Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom
5) Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow
6) Skies of Arcadia (Legends)
7) Hotel Dusk: Room 215
8) XCOM 2: War of the Chosen
9) Metroid Dread
10) Splatoon 3
11) Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King
12) Ghost Trick
13) The Ninja Warriors Once Again (Ninja Saviors)
14) Spiritfarer
15) Portal
16) Super Smash Bros. Ultimate
17) Unicorn Overlord
18) Dead Space 2
19) Untitled Goose Game
20) Celeste
21) Another Code: Recollection
22) Capcom Vs. SNK 2
23) The Last Story
24) Street Fighter 6
25) Shovel Knight: Shovel of Hope (specifically)
Yeah one of my first thoughts when this list came up was “hang on, Suikoden III is 21st century??”
Johnny Unusual
(He/Him)
Yeah, apologies. I forgot to give myself time for this so I'll take the L and do this one next week. Sorry folks (because this is a good one).
Johnny Unusual
(He/Him)
Host: @Lokii
Participants: @Falselogic @Doctor Nerd @JBear @Bulgakov @Johnny Unusual @Daikaiju @Issun @ajr82 @Dracula @Kirin @Gerad @WildcatJF @Kishi @breakman @RT-55J @Torzelbaum Galadrome @Octopus Prime @Mogri
Lokii outdid himself with this one, a top-notch list that not only had art for every entry but art for a ton of bonus entries. Even the characters he doesn’t like. Very clear he doesn’t like Geno. Me, I’ll defend Waluigi. I don’t really follow the memes, I just like copies of copies of copies until it mutates beyond anything normal. But the whole thing is just filled with the most delightful art you can imagine from one of our favourite Talking Time artists. I definitely remember this being a highlight and it is followed by a sequel down the line we’ll get to. I can’t imagine how exhausting it must have been to do. And in under a month, no less. The Talking Time of 2017 was a different place and as much as I like Talking Time of now, I do miss the days where we had way too much time on our hands.
Anyway, this art rules.
And remember…
Participants: @Falselogic @Doctor Nerd @JBear @Bulgakov @Johnny Unusual @Daikaiju @Issun @ajr82 @Dracula @Kirin @Gerad @WildcatJF @Kishi @breakman @RT-55J @Torzelbaum Galadrome @Octopus Prime @Mogri
50. Reznor
49. Bowser Jr. - tie
49. Funky Kong - tie
48. Dry Bones - tie
48. Culex - tie
47. Mr. L
46. Geno - tie
46. Wart - tie
45. Rawk Hawk - tie
45. Lady Bow - tie
44. Mallow
43. Iggy Koopa
42. Doopliss
41. Koopa Troopa - tie
41. Captain Syrup - tie
40. Unagi the Eel
39. Lemmy Koopa
38. Big Boo
37. The Axem Rangers
36. Kuribo's Shoe - tie
36. Roy Koopa - tie
35. Piranha Plant
34. Angry Sun
33. Tatanga
32. Goomba
31. Donkey Kong
30. Wendy O. Koopa
29. Mouser
28. Vivian
27. Princess Daisy - tie
27. Ludwig Von Koopa - tie
26. Pauline
25. Raphael the Raven
24. Kamek
23. Hammer Bros.
22. Thwomp
21. Booster
20. Bullet Bill
19. Fabulous
18. Mario
17. Boo
16. Goombella
15. Phanto
14. Captain Toad
13. Toad
12. Bob-Omb
11. Rosalind
10. Chain Chomp
9. Lakitu
8. Birdo
7. Yoshi
6. Waluigi
5. Shy Guy
4. Princess Peach
3. Wario
2. Bowser
1. Luigi
49. Bowser Jr. - tie
49. Funky Kong - tie
48. Dry Bones - tie
48. Culex - tie
47. Mr. L
46. Geno - tie
46. Wart - tie
45. Rawk Hawk - tie
45. Lady Bow - tie
44. Mallow
43. Iggy Koopa
42. Doopliss
41. Koopa Troopa - tie
41. Captain Syrup - tie
40. Unagi the Eel
39. Lemmy Koopa
38. Big Boo
37. The Axem Rangers
36. Kuribo's Shoe - tie
36. Roy Koopa - tie
35. Piranha Plant
34. Angry Sun
33. Tatanga
32. Goomba
31. Donkey Kong
30. Wendy O. Koopa
29. Mouser
28. Vivian
27. Princess Daisy - tie
27. Ludwig Von Koopa - tie
26. Pauline
25. Raphael the Raven
24. Kamek
23. Hammer Bros.
22. Thwomp
21. Booster
20. Bullet Bill
19. Fabulous
18. Mario
17. Boo
16. Goombella
15. Phanto
14. Captain Toad
13. Toad
12. Bob-Omb
11. Rosalind
10. Chain Chomp
9. Lakitu
8. Birdo
7. Yoshi
6. Waluigi
5. Shy Guy
4. Princess Peach
3. Wario
2. Bowser
1. Luigi
Lokii outdid himself with this one, a top-notch list that not only had art for every entry but art for a ton of bonus entries. Even the characters he doesn’t like. Very clear he doesn’t like Geno. Me, I’ll defend Waluigi. I don’t really follow the memes, I just like copies of copies of copies until it mutates beyond anything normal. But the whole thing is just filled with the most delightful art you can imagine from one of our favourite Talking Time artists. I definitely remember this being a highlight and it is followed by a sequel down the line we’ll get to. I can’t imagine how exhausting it must have been to do. And in under a month, no less. The Talking Time of 2017 was a different place and as much as I like Talking Time of now, I do miss the days where we had way too much time on our hands.
Anyway, this art rules.
And remember…
I also did not vote for Geno. I did vote for Samus, though, since she sorta shows up in the same game he's from.
My #3 was the Pile-Driver Micro Goomba, just because, and I was pleased as punch that Lokii did a runner-up entry for it.
No love for MIPS the rabbit though.
My #3 was the Pile-Driver Micro Goomba, just because, and I was pleased as punch that Lokii did a runner-up entry for it.
No love for MIPS the rabbit though.
Every time I try to give him a big ol' snuggly-huggly he runs away!
- Booster (Super Mario RPG)
- Kuribo's Shoe (Super Mario Bros. 3)
- Bowser (Various)
- Pidgit (Super Mario Bros. 2)
- Percy (Super Talking Time Bros.)
- Mario (Various)
- Jimmy T. (Wario Ware, Inc.)
- Wario (various)
- Yoshi (Various)
- Big Boo (Various)
- Major Burrows (Super Mario Galaxy)
- Goombella (The Thousand Year Door)
- Luigi (Various)
- Rosalina (Super Mario Galaxy)
- Peach (Various)
- Lucas (The Wizard)
- Kamek (Yoshi's Island)
- Wendy O. Koopa (Various)
- Shuyguy (Various)
- Culex (Super Mario RPG)
- Vivian (The Thousand Year Door)
- Bouldergeist (Super Mario Galaxy)
- Luwig von Koopa (Various)
- Raphael the Raven (Yoshi's Island)
- Waluigi (Mario Kart Series)