air_show
elementary my dear baxter
Ok, so here's what got me thinking along these lines. I'm indulging some childish nostalgia on Disney+ and watching bits of Duck Tales and other 80s/90s Disney cartoons and I recently watched the first episode of Tale Spin. Not a bad show. Great music, though I think the opening kind of sucks and doesn't fit the high adventure tone. And now that I'm an old man, it's very, VERY noticeable that Baloo is not being voiced by Phil Harris. Which is understandable, the man was 85 at the time. The replacement does an admirable enough job, but it's still a bit distracting to me at times. At least it's not as bad as Jim Cummings' Tigger, which just makes it impossible for me to truly enjoy any Pooh content made past the original three shorts.
And it occasionally reminds me just how magnificent a lot of those old voices were. Phil Harris, Sebastion Cabot, Paul Winchell, these voices weren't just distinctive, but iconic. They didn't just give these characters personality, they made them unforgettable. And when I try to think of modern voice actors who give me the same chills, I often find myself drawing a blank.
Two who do come to mind for me are JK Simmons and Maria Bamford. Though in Bamford's case what's interesting is that despite her career being born out of doing wacky, cartoonish voices, her voice roles in cartoons seem to always be much more subdued, grounded personalities where you can barely tell it's her. Which should absolutely not be held against her because she nevertheless injects those characters with incredible believability and heart, but it's not that same in your face instant memorability as a lot of classic cartoon voices have.
And it occasionally reminds me just how magnificent a lot of those old voices were. Phil Harris, Sebastion Cabot, Paul Winchell, these voices weren't just distinctive, but iconic. They didn't just give these characters personality, they made them unforgettable. And when I try to think of modern voice actors who give me the same chills, I often find myself drawing a blank.
Two who do come to mind for me are JK Simmons and Maria Bamford. Though in Bamford's case what's interesting is that despite her career being born out of doing wacky, cartoonish voices, her voice roles in cartoons seem to always be much more subdued, grounded personalities where you can barely tell it's her. Which should absolutely not be held against her because she nevertheless injects those characters with incredible believability and heart, but it's not that same in your face instant memorability as a lot of classic cartoon voices have.
Last edited: